Opening the Word: The problem of a pure gift


One of the major questions that has occupied the attention of philosophers in the 20th century is whether it’s possible to offer a pure gift.

What’s meant by a pure gift? A pure gift is something that is given by a person without any strings attached. A parent would feed and love a child without any self-interest. The parent wouldn’t care about the affections involved in the act of parenting. The parent would never think about any future responsibilities that the child would have to the parent — showing up at holidays, calling on Sundays or taking care of the parent in old age.

Many philosophers have argued that this pure gift is impossible precisely because we are always self-interested. We always give a gift in order to get something in return — even if it’s the good feeling of offering the gift to another.

Of course, the problem with this argument is that it presumes that the individual should not be attached to others. It presumes that what would make a gift “pure” is total and absolute altruism, no attachment to those whom we love.

Scripture has another sense of gift. In Habakkuk, we hear the prophet cry out for divine assistance. The God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob has made a covenant with Israel. And the prophet wonders when God will act on his end of the bargain.

The Lord offers a vision to the prophet. God doesn’t say, “Don’t ask for anything from me. I’m God and you’re not.” Instead, God asks for faith from the prophet. God will act. God still has a gift to give.

Jesus addresses the disciples relative to this faith. We’re used to hearing about the mustard seed, the bush that begins as a tiny seed. It is the seed that grows large enough that a bird may nest in its branches.

But Luke’s account of the mustard seed is different. The faith of the mustard seed is a miraculous faith, capable of transplanting a mulberry bush into the middle of the sea. It makes the impossible become possible.

The disciple has this faith. And the reward for this faith, this obedience to God, is not immediately evident. The disciple should not expect rewards aplenty for possessing this faith in the present.

Disciples are servants. They have been given the gift of being in relationship to God. Their response of obedience is dependent on the wondrous decision of God to enter into a relationship with them. As servants, they have acted in a way that is the bare minimum, a return-gift of love to the God who first loved them.

But this doesn’t mean that eventually there will not be a reward. Even the servant should expect to sit down and eat.

God provides this for the servant, who is simply doing his duty. God provides because God is pure gift, pure love, purity itself.

As Christians, we thus have something to say about the supposed goodness of “pure” love. For us, the only pure love is the divine love made incarnate in Jesus Christ. It is a gift beyond gift.

We can’t offer a return gift of love that is this pure because we’re not God. We’re just doing our duty, responding to a love first received.

And rather than see this as a problem, it’s good news.

Being a servant to a God this loving, this capable of fulfilling the promise of redemption, is more than enough.

It is what brings us week after week to the Eucharistic altar.

27th Sunday in Ordinary Time – Oct. 6
Hab 1:2-3; 2:2-4
Ps 95:1-2, 6-7, 8-9;
2 Tm 1:6-8, 13-14
Lk 17: 5-10

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Turkey’s invasion of Syria strikes a blow against Christians

Wednesday, October 23, 2019
By: Edward Clancy President Donald Trump’s order to withdraw U.S. troops from northeastern Syria effectively greenlit Turkey’s invasion... Read More

Not so great expectations

Monday, October 21, 2019
By: Teresa Tomeo Most moms and dads have great dreams for their children to grow up and do something that matters. From a Catholic perspective,... Read More

Opening the Word: The myth of self-reliance

Friday, October 18, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Nineteenth-century American thought often praised the virtue of self-reliance. The self-reliant person was not dependent on... Read More

Sins against the Sixth Commandment at the root of clericalism

Wednesday, October 16, 2019
By: Dr. Greg Popcak Pope Francis is well-known for his attacks against clericalism — the tendency for clergy to act as if they are better... Read More

Lessons to be learned from Halloween, All Saints Day

Monday, October 14, 2019
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion I have a routine. Every year on Oct. 31 I go to the nearby drugstore and buy several bags of candy. Then, when I reach my... Read More

Opening the Word: Salvific gratitude

Friday, October 11, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley We form our children from an early age to express gratitude. When we fetch them a cup of water and an afternoon snack, we... Read More

Pro-life leaders say drop in abortion rate worth celebrating, but grave concerns remain

Wednesday, October 9, 2019
By: Brian Fraga A recent Guttmacher Institute report indicates that the national abortion rate is at its lowest point since the procedure became... Read More

British royalty at Newman canonization

Monday, October 7, 2019
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion In a few days, Cardinal John Henry Newman will be canonized as a saint, and Britain’s Prince Charles is scheduled... Read More

Opening the Word: The problem of a pure gift

Friday, October 4, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley One of the major questions that has occupied the attention of philosophers in the 20th century is whether it’s... Read More

Texas bishop says he is saddened that defending the Gospel is considered ‘bold’

Wednesday, October 2, 2019
By: Michael R. Heinlein But Bishop Strickland’s staunch defense of Church teaching and strong advocacy for transparency in the wake of the... Read More

Online Giving

Online Giving

Secure and Convenient Donate now!